Is This About My Relationship, or About Me? Why Individual Therapy Matters in CNM

When people begin exploring opening up a relationship, or stepping into some form of Consensual Non-Monogamy (CNM) for the first time, it often feels exhilarating. There’s novelty, possibility, and the rush of New Relationship Energy (NRE) that can make everything seem expansive and aligned.

But as the initial excitement settles, questions and discomfort can start to surface. Maybe something feels off, tender, or confusing, and you’re left wondering:

Is this something we need to work on together? Or something I need to sort out on my own? 

A person stands alone in the warm light of the setting sun, deep in thought.

You might find yourself going back and forth:

• Do we need couples therapy?

• Should I work through this individually first?

• Is something actually wrong or am I just overthinking? 

Often, the most honest answer isn’t either/or, but both/and.

Why CNM Brings Relational Patterns to the Surface

Exploring Consensual Non-monogamy has a way of bringing certain themes into sharper focus; not because something is broken, but because the relational structure itself is changing. What a monogamous framework may have once obscured can become harder to ignore or avoid. As familiar agreements shift, patterns that were always present often become more visible.

This can include things like:

• How you experience jealousy, insecurity, or uncertainty

• How you set—or avoid—boundaries

• How you navigate attachment, reassurance, and independence

• How comfortable you are naming needs or tolerating discomfort

• Where you tend to prioritize connection over self-trust

These aren’t signs of “relationship failure.” They’re deeply human patterns that tend to surface when we’re asked to relate in new and unfamiliar ways.

What Individual Therapy Can Offer

Individual therapy isn’t about deciding whether CNM is “right” or “wrong,” or about assigning blame to you or your partner(s). It is a space to slow down and ask more curious, self-directed questions, such as:

• What do I need in order to feel grounded and emotionally safe?

• How do I respond when things feel uncertain or out of my control?

• Where do I override my own needs to preserve connection?

• What does autonomy actually look like for me in practice?

Even in relationships that are communicative, intentional, and caring, individual therapy can support differentiation: the ability to stay connected without losing connection to yourself. For many people exploring any form of CNM, that capacity becomes especially important.

In a cozy living room, a person connects to a telehealth therapy session via smartphone.

You Don’t Have to Be in Crisis

A common hesitation is the belief that therapy is only for moments of conflict, distress, or breakdown. But often, people seek individual therapy not because something is wrong, but because something is changing. And they want to meet that change with more awareness.

You don’t need a clear problem to justify getting support. You don’t need to be certain what you’re working toward. And you don’t need to have it all figured out before you begin.

Sometimes the most meaningful relational work starts quietly, with a deeper understanding of yourself: your limits, your longings, and the ways you’ve learned to stay connected.

If you’re wondering whether this is about your relationship or about you, individual therapy can offer a space to explore that question, without the pressure to have an immediate answer or to articulate everything perfectly in front of a partner.

A Note About My (Amanda’s) Approach

Early in my work, I sometimes joked that I sounded like a marketing oxymoron: a polyamory-affirming therapist who works exclusively with individuals.

A throwback photo of therapist, Amanda, in 2019 when she opened her practice

For a while, I wondered if that would feel confusing, especially for people navigating CNM and trying to decide where to focus their energy. Over time, I’ve come to see that this focus is intentional, not limiting.

My work centers on helping people explore and strengthen intrapersonal trust, which encompasses the ability to listen to yourself, stay oriented to your values, and make choices that feel grounded rather than reactive. When relational structures change, that internal relationship often becomes the most important anchor.

I’ve developed a specialized process for people who are questioning, opening, renegotiating, or deepening within their Consensual Non-Monogamous relationships. My aim is not to steer them toward any particular outcome, but to help them understand their own patterns, limits, and capacities more clearly. From that clarity, people tend to make more sustainable relational decisions, whether individually or together.

Because I work closely with these questions, I’m able to recognize when individual therapy is the most important next step for addressing what’s coming up, as well as suggesting when couples or relationship therapy might provide additional support. I draw on my experience and connections with a trusted network of CNM-affirming colleagues to offer guidance and referrals thoughtfully, always in partnership with you.

If coordinating care feels useful, I can be involved as much or as little as you’d like, whether this means evaluating all resources and supports available, collaborating behind the scenes with other clinicians, or stepping back once a referral is in place.

The goal isn’t to keep you in individual therapy, but to support you in building clarity and self-trust so you can access the support that truly fits.

A Gentle Next Step

If you’re in a place of questioning your CNM relationship, yourself, or what kind of support might be most helpful, you don’t need to decide everything at once.

Sometimes starting with a conversation is enough.

Click Here to Learn More